Paul Scholes Names ‘Perfect’ Next Man United Manager as Michael Carrick Questioned
Former Paul Scholes, the celebrated Manchester United midfielder, has publicly named Carlo Ancelotti as the “perfect” choice to take over as Manchester United’s permanent manager — a view that comes amid strong debate over current interim boss Michael Carrick.
Scholes acknowledged Carrick’s stunning short-term start in charge which has seen the Red Devils remain unbeaten in his first seven league games — but questioned whether Carrick has the experience and pedigree required to lead the club long-term.
Scholes pointed to Ancelotti’s extensive trophy-winning record and man-management qualities as key reasons why the veteran coach would be an ideal fit for Manchester United’s permanent role. Although Ancelotti is currently managing the Brazil national football team, Scholes believes the Italian’s ability to get the best out of elite players and his calm presence could provide the stability and leadership United has lacked in recent years.
Carrick’s interim reign has been notable: Manchester United climbed the Premier League table with a string of positive results, including six wins and a draw in his first seven matches. This form has strengthened his case internally with some within the club viewing him as a strong candidate for the permanent job.
Despite this momentum, Scholes’ comments underline a broader conversation about whether experience or current form should carry greater weight in United’s summer managerial decision.
The debate highlights two contrasting philosophies: rewarding Carrick’s unexpected success and familiarity with the club, or appointing a seasoned manager like Ancelotti who has won major trophies at multiple top-level clubs. The club’s recruitment strategy remains under scrutiny as supporters and pundits weigh in ahead of the official appointment window.
